
ڱضԴȨ

ɵ.  Ronald Dworkin

    ¼䣬һйܣȥμӱ廪ѧѧԺһΪʱ
ֻᣬȻιڽ廪ֻ廪ѧġ
Ȩоġģ廪ԼطеĽͻ̸УҪ
ۺϷԣlegalityȨλںݵ㽭ѧģ༴
Ľ⣬ "ԴȨΪɺ
߳¼һҪ̸̸ЩʱЩ¡йĮӷΡ
ѹȫַȨļ¼ǳģЩѧͺй
һնִĹƿ֮ѽ
    ȷй쵼˷˵غ͹ΣΪǸͶ
ó׵Ļ 1999꣬л񹲺͹ܷ޸ĺĴǣ
л񹲺͹ʵι巨ιҡǣʵʵķʵ
°Уǡìܡԭ򣺹ҵǿ
ȨֻܸѾȷı׼ʹٱȨͳ
йʵųԭ෴ȴѭ泣ҵĹ۵㣺Ɏշǹغ
һԡ֡£Ǭǹغ尸еĵԡйķ
ûнƶȣǲԴΡ÷ںİӦѡǰ
ԡ򡡴ڣֻкٵ˾лù
    ڹ߶ȡȨʱѧ˵ȡѧ˵Ȩ
οƵĹߣñڴ޲׼ڵĹרǽ
һֶʽķϵġϵͳϵͳΪн
ηһԵľѺе޼ҿɹʧҵũ
ҡͶϵڷڼĵǿ˵ĸĸѾ
ȵؼ˹ϵͳĻضΡƶѷϳǣķ
شȱݡ෡ǾյĻԱﾾûܹ۷
ѵ˹ܡա쵼Ȼ޹˼ɵʹ³ʽˡԼ
ա߻Ρ˸˵Ŀġ磡ȡգľ촡й
̦ҡϻŽУѺڿἡ̦ݱ֡
ԱΡĸԱˡظܵˡٱ绤еšǣ
ɹŦԼѡйǧסҽסƶerome Cohenڣ֪Ϊ
αءδ͡ˡΥйķɡһЩţս
ɹ̷̦ʹα֤Ĺ涨ܵߣʹˡ̦أΡ
ǵˤѶ֡³ڷͥϷбڷɵ
ĹصӡҡıѡѡںĻ֡
йʻաı绤̡̦ˡ繡ˤ˸ı⣡
ջعܻᱻһʲ۷ɣ
    йȨ¼ͬ⡣2002Ȩָ2001й
Ȩ¼ʵϴñʱй۵ġϻ
ͷű˵йǧֲͬߺȨӼ
վĥд468˰̰۵ȷķ̣
κңֹԱڼŰ26˹
ᵽ鳡һڼйۿ¼Ĳ帾Ůꡣ
£ʢʱйһδдá
ֹ˰չķǷģutlawedйԱʮʮһڣҺʹ
찲ŵThe Tiananmen PapersǣһܵĹ1989
찲Ǵɱı棬йΪɢ 
    ǿǵһ¼ұ˵Ľݺʽʽ
𾪡廪ĵһҪֵ̽ǷΣйձҵĸ
ѧѧǷԼĹ۵㣬ڶʦ١ѧڡѧҺ
ѧҲμۡ˺߶ɺͷѧ˽㷺
۵ӡ󡣺üλָйƶȵȱݣ̹෨ȱ
Ǹݷɣǵ»аһЩǡ
Ľ飺磬ǽӦ˾Թϣɴ˲˾
ƶȣҼ˾ܣ߷۱һЩָй
Ժͬ߷ԺӦȨƷΥйܷ
ɡ󲿷ۼڹڹεĻԭԭۻķ
ѧ⡣磬ѧǺ۱磬Ǽʦ뷨¼ֵ
ȷϷɵҪķʵ֤ڷΪ֣Ϊһ
Ӧݵ嶨ɹԭһӸӵķΪ
۳ζҴлࡣǣһǿԼڷ֮ϣ
Ϊίڴ֮·ʦĹңƺ˼عڳ
ˡ
    廪ڶĻϣԼڱ廪ѧйѧϺĸ
ѧںݵ㽭ѧ۴ѧݽУԼڡ顷־һ
й֪ʶӿ賓עһҴ꡶ʢ԰ټ̸ϣ
ҸΪֱ˵̸Ȩ˵ձţΪ
ոԺĹ۵㣬йĴͳ֧Ԯ߼ġٸ
ĹڹȨεĹ۵㡣йӵν޼ֵνġ
ֵڸȨ档ҽ飬̽һ϶һ
첻档˵ɼΪù㷺ͬȨֲ
ԭ֮Уһÿһŵ˵˾ͬҪڶˣÿ
˾ÿһĳɹضΩԼˡ˵
һԭϽΪ˵ΪĳЩ˵棬
ʲΪ˶˶ŰϵķɣйصͶ
غҡҵۿڳеĲƸũе˿ڣδܻʷй
ľ÷١ڶԡҡաظΡˡǵɡȡ
ˡ˹ȡŷκڽ̵ȡաκ͵Ŀ
ȡաۡΡ˶ȡйַڶԡΡ
ཡֲ͡ߣϽй֡աλûκաĿģ
ںԼڽ൱ǧڼͿķֹ
ʣķԡҴҡ֡Ӧ繡Ƿ
ԡۣˡǷԣˡǵۡ˵Ըһָٸ
ģ޵ġԡҲ˵ҷš޼ֵ͡
ֵǳ϶Ի󲻽ġϾǵ
ĻشǷ͡ﾵ״ҡϡ
ǿһпɵõԴʹǵɡ
ԼĶˡ˵崻ĹĻұ˵йѡߺѡ
۱ֻǱֳġʡ˶ڹʾ뷢˲͡Ŀ
е淡ǶԴȺ̡ݽұ֡νͼΡ˳00
0˵ڣԣҶݽܼ֮۸еȡÿһĳϣ
ʵʱ䶼ӳˡЩѧֵ⣬̸ľõ۹
19995¶ڱйʹݵĺը˵ⲻ
йڲ̸ͬһѧߺʹ󲿷ѧϣ
Ȩļֵ͸Լ֮ĎʲشĲ
    ڹҴͳǷȷǳ϶ͬ˶
ͳϣһ߾ζ۱廪ѧ
һȷйĻʷǹڷԼļֵ۱硣廪ѧ
ھʹ˼ȵĳƪԡ˵Ļ龳Ȼһģ
Ҳ̸ͬйֵй뿪ʼ˵ĸ
ֵġ˶˵󣬴ȺڴعơÿһУҽ
йȨйȨַҪ˹ӵ
ֵڸۡ û˳֪Щİ˽»йѧߺ
ż˵ȫܵģ˵Ϣͨѧߣ
Ȩ¼Ҳ֪Ȼɹ涨Ӧ˹涨
ˣڶֵѧʵ֮ļͻ
Ҫ⡣ںѧǲ֪ἰδѹȵ
尸Ҳ֪Ǿģ˵Ǳضٳڽ
ҵͬʱһλͬѧش˵ʱʱͻȻ;УۣΪʲ
Щ˹ӵ֮ʿղηܵͷΡˡǶй
աաķйطεĵжԸ֡۱ǡʱǷ
ǳȵģˡļֵЩǷѿҡҡö࣡й
һΡܵǰ;ġ˶屵ȵȣƺ
˵ֹأһ۰צĽƺֵó͡йѡߺ֡Ȼ
ţӦͷͼֹѡ̳ϻˡЩγա
˶ˤĳУڸͶȡĸѵı롣м˸
ң쵼˶ڵ͡˶ȡտܻ͡ķʽɥʡ
һǷǳ峡ġˣκֱǷֹķա
ֳǧڼʾ͡߾гκ硶찲ŵ
鼡Щпڵĵ쵼ˣ𺦵ˡǵĸ˵λǣ
ﳶֻ۱һѡ۵뷡Ĵѡ¡ղ£ʵ
Ρ۲ҵĽʱұ΢ظ֡ҿܴ˳ͷ

    ѧǹֻҪǽѧ˵ǾǰȫǷţ
󡣽ܳойѧPerry Linkд
ʲ۽ܵͷĲȷԣΪһߡҵȫУ
һȷҲǿҵĸоһλйרңһ
ڷйڼҪйѧߡʦͼߵֻе
һλ绰˼档ӿȵػʱ
飬Ǽ棬ܾͼġȻѾλ
еһЩȷҪͲҪй¶˸ҵǷһЩ֎ղá
ϵĶԴ˱ʾԾһЩáֲáϱʾʡɣڴ
ѡоɳԡ磡Ƕ˵˻ڿšա
աߡաѹȳҰͻϵģƺʵġ
աΡλʵǱڵ͡ģֹաη
ɡˡղʵȡλ˼ơҸеǷݶǰ;ֹȴ
ҡһ͡Ľ͡ʣ뼸ǰȣ֡Ӻѡ
ĸ˾öˡйµɷľѡաɵķ٣
ڴϡ̵͸еڶཨ֡ϣĿ֤󲿷˽½̸
ѡƺˡǵľǰ;λաΡ͡Щ쵼̨
µķܵŵʡ͡κ£ٶѡԵģˡ
ڳУ󲿷ֵũǷɣƶѡ֡Ӷڳ
ǵֹܷӳˡǶɡǰ¡㡣
ֹܻӳһ̸ֳաι۵㣡Щա
ա߳Ρ̡ȵ˽ġȻѡߺѡţйҽ
ɣˡе˻Ρ繡ȡνбϡ
е˵Ļ˵ǵйδΡȷŽᵽȡ
óֵġ׼ˡһ̸áˣȷ̡죡
ˡƵġҡ෢ܡȱСܷ߾ֲ

    һ뷨Ļоƽܳѧ͡顷־
༭͵Ľ̸Уұ֪й֪ʶӷֻĹؼǾøĸ賓
ӹתΪɵгӦͬһѸٵ
ݿƷǽģԱ㱣ЩᱻͻȻľƵɻ˺
ˡ θĸٶϣ֪ʶ֮ƺҲŷֻҵУ
ߺʿƺһ׶εοƩرǶ
֯ĹڿͶλĿƩڱǵĳԶĿ˵Ǳ
һ۵㡣һЩ˵öþͿʵЩĿ꣬Ȼǎղʡ峡
һƶܵ
    ӦסҪһǣйĴѧں֪ʶӼᡣ
Ǹ߼ѧߵһˣĸбë󶫻ˡĽʹʧȥ˵ʦ
ͬʱ־Լʱȴǵбǻˣʱ
䲻һվһߡʱһȺѧǵԱճﻡԼ
ɡģȡ˵ǣ˳ﻡˡǣǶԼһ쵼һ
ȡֹܹȡַзǷġˡǲ
ܿ϶ȡһλ˵ȡȻͲðʡˡйѾ
ơáʶ̡ˡ͵ר塣ǣ
Ĺ˿ȴӦһָ϶־õѹʽĻ裺ʶ̡
ӵȡΡի ) 




50
֮  20032¡  ( 117 )






