ʱͻʱ

С


ʱΪҾõĳɹʱĳɹǿˣ
Ļʱ壬йĻʱ壨˳֮ԭʼʱҵʱ
ȴܲɹľ÷չʶɹľ÷չҪгʱ徭
ãҪʵκͷƶȡ

18ʱӢǷңǷչйңĲƶȵĲ
ǰʵרƶȣɻĸĻʱ壬ȴӢ
1688֮ʵƶȡǹҪ֮һȻᵽͣʹ
Ҫ˵һʲôǹͣʲôкܴ졣ӹŵϽ
Ƕ˵ͳΣǿƽȣΣȨǿ档
ʹĳϽΪרƣ˵רƣĺϷȨ
Դȫ幫ںܶʱⲢָ񣩣ĹϵǺܽŵġڹ
˼ڽִ໥ȡںϣڴ˾Ͳ׸ˡƶڵʱ
˵һƶȣһֹƶȡνƶȾǲμѡٵҪһЩϲ
ײ㣬ֻǮ˰˲ѡȨ˵ġǡ͡
˵зȨƺƶȡʵǶĲΣɶѹ
Ӣ1830Ժʵִƶеѡơ

һֱĻơԺܸݵĴСٶ
һƱԿΪԿһơԺǰѡѡ
ȴҪܲǰѡѡĲԺƺ⡣ѡͳѡԺͲԺ
ԡѡƱٵСʲſӮƱĸһԿ
ƶȾǴ󷨹ƶȡٲѡٵģͳģʵơȻͳ
Ȩܹƺ⣬ҲѵлôȨиȱлᣩǿԶԿ
۵ġ˵ɣⲻǾԵġڱ飬͸˵Ǳ
ͿѧӦýɺ͹͡ͳν׼ͱͳν׼ͻ
Ǻܲȶģͳν׼ռϷרƣͳν׼ռϷǸ
ֲǺ顣ǿȨƺ⣬κһѹһ
пֳܱ־õȶͷչ

ݹᣬʱٽõĳչʱ岻ܴڳɹľ
÷չľʽҲǶֶģµƪԺáʱ
ǵһҪ

һӢĳɹһֹƶȡƶȵĳɹƶȲ
ƵȨߵĻ塣ֻжĻסˣòܷչӢ
չһԭǺʱ壬гû¢Ϊ
ǰһֻʱ壬רƣһɡεġר
ЩйʷһЩ񡣱˵㡰桱ר
һΪһѡģĺϷԾʹ⣬̫ߵ˰
췴ġһںϷ⣬ܸߵ˰
ԵʱӢͷչһҪǣӢƽ˰ʱȷҪߵöࡣӢ
˰ܹƽڷкܶǿԲ˰ģȡйԺʿԲ
˰һӢκ˶Ҫ˰Ϊ˰ƽԷƽ˰ʱӢ
ܶ࣬ûģĹҵһرйǹ̹ᡣʱӢ
Ĺ̹ϵԵĳͻǹ̹ᡣӢʱƶȾ
콲ѧξѧｲеһǹĲ͹ҵĲ
ǷֿġһǵʱӢִĲ͹ҵĲǷֿģִִʱ
ܴӮҵ̨80Ժʵй񵳵Ĳ͹ҵĲֿ
ʵִܴӮҵƶȡִӮҵʵ
ΥƶϷģ˵Ϸƶֱ߲ȥȷ˵ֱ
˾ԲñͻӦþеĹԺԡ

ŵ˹¸һƪһ۵㣬Ӣҵĳɹһľ
󣬶1688ٸ˵һϷĻ
ΪͱסˣĻҲ͸żˣԹҵŻӢ
ҲǿɹƭйĿǰǳʢС߳һʮ岻һǹһ
塣ֻƶ£ֱܾܹƽ˵רƶȣûй˽֮
֣ȫģԶעƶȣҲǱ˽ҵʣȨƶȡЩʹ
ü׬ǮӶƶ˼ҵͼЩŻйҵ
ʱǿĿƼƶȣжϽ˭˭谭
ļҵҿһЩʷϣйʷѧһۣݵǮׯ
γʱʹڵģƶȴ¡Ҳ˵йʹڡԭʼʱ塱
ˡںܶʷѧ˶˵û֣йܼͶ빤ҵʱ
ᡣΪʲôأҵʱҪϵķҪרƶȺͶ˽ʣȨ
ıMokyrĿӢҵ50%ϵ¼ûлר
˽ҵʣȨģ

䲻ܶʷѧһۣ18͵ķ䲻
һܶƷΪײģʹгģС
ɱܸߣֹˮƽףЧʺܵ͡ʱӢϹƽΪڷ
ģгģ󣬳ɱ͡䲻谭÷չġ˵䲻
ǷչйҵıȻ۵Ǻֵ÷ʡģΪ漰ʱͻʱ
֮֡ͬʱ;÷չҲǻΪģ˵乫ƽʹþ÷չ죬
÷չʹ乫ƽҲǺʱص㡣

Landes1998Լ̩߰1726-1729ڼӢļ
أӢȾķƽĶࡣCharles marquis de Biencourt
ơӢΪͨ˶ΪLandes1998p.222ڷ
ʱڣ¢ϲЧʲƽƷϰն
ͬʱľΪӢݳƷζţгǳ
ɴ˲˵ˮƽͶֹ͵͵ܺٸӢ;ʱķ
ƶϵֲ𣬲˾ʵ͹ҲƸĲֲǷԭ
֮һMantoux 1962 p.419 ¼ǶֲĸܡArthur
YoungڷʱǷǰҹ֣뷨ڵıҺͿѵĴȣ
ԼҵĴҪõĶࡣУÿһҳ˶Ӣӵеıȷ
ŷ޹ĽԽԺС MokyrĹƣ1993 p.45
1788꣬Ӣ˾GNPȷ߳30%.ϱ޷չĶԱȡ޵Դܷḻ
һֱڷչйҵĵλԴƶȴĵŵ
˹˹Ϊԭ򡣵һʵеطΣӢ£Σ˰
Ҫڵطչֻǰֳؿһ˰ԴطԺ
ͺѷչڶһ½̹ңռƣĻĲ쵼˾
÷չĲͬʵеƣʵеһơҲ漰ʱ
͡ʱ塱֡ʱ˹̹ᡢ¢ϵ֮⣬һԵ
䲻Ļϵߵģﵽ0.60.7.뱱޵ķչ
жԱȺʷѧҽʧķչ̹Ӣŵ¢ϡ
¢ϲ˵Чʲƽ䣬һгС
ĵ¡μīƣSchleiferVishny1989ԼǵĲοףNorth
 Summerhill Weingast2000ڱ޷չıȽϣ

Murphy Shleifer
Vishnyָ18-19͵ĺڣӢƽˣг
ӢLa Porta Lopez-de-Silanes Shleifer  Vishny 
ѾҵһļӾ֤ݡĻع̺ͳ񷨻Ծ
Ӱ죬½̺ͨԾӰġ޺ʱ
ڵĵͳκ¢ϲĴ½ʢеĵû
Ͽɣͽܷչ̵֧ɡͬʱ½ƶģӵкʱ
Ĺ ô󣬰ĴǣӢ½ռƺʵͨĵ
̺ͨǲڲ¢ϵġ½ͽԲκ˵ͬⷢչ½̽ɣ
ͨǻڹƽѶеϰɵϲķɣŷ޴½ʢеĵ
ӢƶȾѹ£ʵܷ˾ƶȣܷͥƺȨ󣬴½
֮ͨĲС

ƺƸʱҲкܴϵơ˼˵
ڷչȽϳ٣кܶණģ·ҡģʽһģƶȣ
һģ¼͹ҵģʽǺ󷢹ңԿûлƶȣر
ƶȣͨģʵֿٷչرģ¼Ƚףģ
ȱȽѣΪҪĸƶȻᴥһЩȵ棬һڼģ¡
Ȼڶȡ÷ǳõķչǻڵķչ
ڷչʧܡ峯˶һӡձǱŵѧ̬
ģʱƶȵġձȫ֪ҵΪʱģ
⣬Ӫҵܿģ󣬻ٲӪҵƶҲ
ѧɺΣֻǲϷʵʵȨǺ˶йȴ
ڲƶȵ£ùƣٰ죩ҵ̺ϰ죩аƣٶ
죩ͨģ¼ʵֹҵڵʱЧȻù˶ǰйá
ȴʹһƶȻϷƶߣǲмԱ˽
˾޷Ȥǣ˶ֹӪҵλ¢
Դܶ˽ҵĲӪҵо峯˶˻ʱ塣

죬Ƕֹּٰ֪ҵƶǳ²ࡣǣ8090
йùƣٰ죩ҵ̺ϰ죩аƣٶ̰죩ͨģ
ۺ̨ܼƷڵ¹ҵģʽģ¼ʵֹҵܶ
ҵҲ൱˶еĹ̺ϰ͹ٶ̰졣ּƶȣڽȴ
˵ǡƶȴ¡Ȼģʽ൱ɹǴӶĽѵǿԿ
ֶڵĳɹǺơüģ´ƶȸĸʱ
塣

ġ¢¢ϲʱ壬һķչˡʷѧҽŷ
ҵͳɹľ÷չ鹦ŷεĲͳһԼжԵͳ֮ľ
¢ϡⷽĵBaechlerĹ۲ 1976p.80ʱŵĸԴ
һͬһڼĹ棬һ棬εĶԪԸ÷չɡ

Baechler 1976 pp.78-79 ͼ¢ûŷʢеԭ
ζԪԭǸӵģַչУҿԿһʷ漣Ҳ
˵һּ˲ܵʷ¼еȨھԻ¢ϲ
һΪһЩáǽ̻ĴڡΪ̻Ŀʺ
ѱաΣǷȨķ⽨ƶµᾫӢ ǲΪ
Լеķչʲ׼ĳɳڹҵƶȡҿ
ʮһӢģʽ˵ӰҪġ

һ۶ϵõѧߺʷѧҰHall 1987 Mokyr 1990 Jones
1981 pp. 226-35 Braudel 1984 pp.128-9 Weber Macfarlane
1988 pp.186-7 McNeill 1974 Laslett 1988 p.235
HoffmanNorberg 1994 Լ Landes 1998 p.36 ͬMcNeill 1974
p.125
ִָŷڵζԪΪǸĺڲͬԭִڵ
ǰһЩķӦǹ̺ǿӴȨҵȨŷ
ŷĵطķӦȴǸʶͬǵھչʱͨƽķ
ʽͨսķʽչһθ֣һ̼ʶ
̬֮𣬲ʹκһƵļ֮𻨵ԭHoffman 
Norberg 1994ִָ֮ŷڣеľʵǵԸʱ
òǿϰ̸У̣ʱǻ¸κξܵõ
 p.305.жôԸרǲǮ˰ġֻ
ǿصſܳȡ޶˰գٽǮơ˰רìܵġ
һǿһǿеĹҲıҪǰᡱp.310Landesָ
רŷҲǴڵġרƱɺָˡͬʱڹ
ڲ루Ȩ͵ط⽨֮ȨָҲרơѲ˾
ڱõĹƴǣǻܵĵطȥͳһĴ۹
ܣйرǵǰԼΪʱǻ޴ӡ
岻ַ˽˲Ʋҵ ҲýǮΣķ˹
Ը˺͹˾ξΪĹơʱһصǽǮΡ
ΪʮͣͳξӢ¢йҪԭ򡣡ᣬ뼯Ȩ
֯£ƶ¢˼дģ£ڽԼ
ģûˣ˽ҵûйٷӻʱչһֱڹٷĿ
֮£ΪٷˣǱٷûեȡԱ˻档
Etienne Balazsָҵܹٷ˰ԼԼҪƷ¢ϣ
ڹŴκڽԲ裬˿̲ݺͻ¢ϣӵ
ɵľȨûκ˽ײ㱻زַЩȨʵУ˽
˲ȨӽһǿľȨٷıӻ֧Ǵҵҵ
չΨһ;Ľγһ˺͹Ա֮յ湲ͬ塭֮ܶ
ʱ֮ûйչԴڣڵʿԼڹƶ
еĴ˵йҵûпܽFairbank1992 p.179Mokyr
 Ҳָ1990 p.236 NeedhamĻйһֱǡһרĹҡ.ǧ
һֱҵͳΡ峯ʱڣѹ֪ʶӺ˵Ĳ
йûŷּ˵ڽȺŷȣйС߳-ң
˼Ĵ˿ӱܵĵط Elvin 1973ָйγʱҵ
ͼͺܺõطչˡȻ¢Ϻͻʱƣû
չĹҵ׶Ρ 2002ch.1Ϊŷ޵ֶԪ֤˼
ȨԽӽƽȵĵλ໥ս෴ǵĵԵνṹȴ֤
֮ǰйİȨλû⡣ձˣɹ˺
ϱйǳйͳййһ½ңӮ
һͳһս½óȴǰġˣֱձά֮ǰڶǣ
ĶԶԶСŷ

κСLiu and Yang2001һģ֤롣֤
ڲ¢ϵгУͶֹһˮƽܺڴ¢
геˮƽʱг֮Ʒг¢ϵĲû
ɽ룬Ȼ¢ϲŵķɹɶۣɶۣ̰ܻߣ
¢ʹ¢ϵĲŵķʴμ۸ߣЧʵĲƽȣ¢ϵĲ
Ż˻ô¢󣬶ܰͣг
չкھ÷չ¢ɵСг󾭼ò
־òʱеľѭȫͬ¢εĳʽ
̰۸벻¢ϵгȣ¢Ͻҵ̶ȣгһ廯
̶ȣг̶ȣͿԱõȽƣԼְҵ;ýṹĶ̶ȡ

Ӣٸǰɽϰҵ¢ȨΪ־ North
1981 Morky 1990 1993 .й1950-1990ڼ䣬¢ɽκ
ܶҵϰΪвţóţۺҵԼʮ
¢ϣ׼˽˾Ӫ֤ƶȣҵƶȣԼ񻧿ڵǼƶ
ȶֹɽͼҵģSachsWoo2001Է
ȺҲִֹǽ̨һԶ׼¢Ϊ
