תڼ

йչ


 ƽ


      ƪµĿܴдһ鶼δؽȫ£ֻԼ
ʵϵ϶ࡢ϶ԼŤý϶ࡢͬʱҲΪ϶
ۡ

һйεļһ

      (1)
      ֽͨΡ
      ִѧĶܶ࣬ͬС졣ѧͿϴ(Aus
tin Ranney  Willmoore Kendall)¹һĶ:
;ѡķʽȡò¼ߵĿȨ֯塣
      ִʵгڣвμǷ(Ԫ
ѫʢ١ѷ)ΪܰΣų֮ʿʹ
ȨԭΪջеɾͻеԣͿܽ춹桢
֮ϣͿܳ춵Զݣ˴֮Ϊ˷Զԣʹ
ţܵ·ѣ⣬ееͣ˵Աɺ
ȵȡ
      ƽĶֹۣ۵㲢Ǻ޸ݣ£
ǳˣҳΪεĳ̬ڽУûһͨ
ʵġΪʵ䲻ĹܣΪ衣

      ִ֪ƻ϶Ǽƶֱƣѡ
Ȩ˭Ҫִ˭ͱõڵ֧ܱ֡(J.A.Schum
peter)Ķ壬νǡΪﵽξһƶϵİţ
ְУĳЩͨȡѡƱõȨΪӮѡ٣
˵޲ɣһܲ֯ΪʹԼű
ߣɷ֯ͨʤ֮֯־ͬ
ͬܶγɸϾ͸ȡóɹ
УΣʽеĵִ̨е
̨ƺ⣬ιȽϷҲǲƵһԽԡ
      ѡĽǶȿѡѡ񡣲ͬΪѡṩ
ͬѡͣѡԸһ˵Ƚ׵ȷ
ͱûѡÿһĺѡ˷ֱѡ
ˡʱ򣬴Լû֯ε򻮷ȷɱ
ȴҪǵʶϲͬĵɱǩɼڹβ
εĽǶȳҲģҪġ
      ֪һרƵͳһ򷴶Զ൳ƣڮΣǣ
εɺͻʢ١ѷɸͬ෴ǡǡһ
רƣеıײ򼫶ˡǡǡһר֮£ɳ׵
죬ʹȨԭ򳹵׳գһϣѹ
档Ҳǡǡһר֮£ԱųΪĹߣĹߣԱ
ɺͶ⵽׵İᡣ

      (2)Ĵ
      ΪԼһר绤ʱʹֲͬ˵ʡͨ
ǿԼĽ׼ԣԼ޲׼ͳͳɡ
׼ϡѹʱǿԼȫԣȻ
йӲԳȫ񵳣껹Ժ³ȫ񵳴УⲢ
һַʽǿԼȫԡй޲׼ʷչķ޲
׼ȫһ£˹Ҳȫ
û֯
      ˵ڴûŵˣаȴ
Ȼһ⡣һĳһضȺĴأȫĹ
ͬ?ǽ׼أȫ?
      еԼĳ׼ĳȺĴ˵ȴҪ
ĳ׼ĳȺ塣еĵϾдԼһԣƩ繤˵
ũ񵳡ŮȤǣټʲôȡʱҵԵ
Ϊˡũ͸ŮȺ壬Ϊڶ࣬Ǵ
Ƶλ߼֮ǵΪ٣Ⱥֲ֧Ӯ
Ⱥͬ顣ҪǴռǿƵȺţҹ
ټ˲á
      Ȼ춣һԼĳһȺ壬һ£Ⱥ
ǷͬͶƱȫһ¡Ůδ㹻
ŮѡƱ͹һܵõ͹֧֡˵йʵΣ
йũռʵƱصũһ󣬳ִӶ
ũѹȺľ档ӾϿֵĲûʲôݡ

      ӡһԸΪĳȺı棬ǣ
Ⱥƫ߿͹δضԸȺ
δϻóɹ߷߶ĳȺȷʵ
ϧǲȺĶԱ⣬㻹ǲܵһɹ⣬
Щ˶ΪĳһȺı棬ԶԸȺܺܲһ
ľҲܺܲһ˱˴֮䶼ܻͬҪŻ
̨壬ǼעĸŮ(йŮйŮ)͹
(л͹ȫ͹)ͬʵĵкüô
ָȺڶ˵һһ?
      ڶϣͬ׼ͬȺ沢Ƕġìܵģ
ǳǹġġƬǿĳһ׼ĳһȺ棬˼δ
˼δ顣ٸŴӲĸ
˵ˣ฾Ů޳ɡΪ֪ëϣĸ
ԽߣˣɷľøͿԽأɷľøأ
ӵҲӰ졣ͬǸŮĸŮܴеõ
ٺôöĸŮմ˴ҵĹ⡣˼
ôʱҵķʽ˵棬ǣ󲿷ֹ֪
沢ֻжԶһԣԺų޲׼ڹ
һӵԽԽӵ
      ͬһ׼ͬһȺĳԱȻشĹͬ棬Ҳܴ
ͻʱڲͳͻⲿķͳ
ͻøֱӣԡһּĳ׼ĳȺʱ
ͷĺֻܿǸý׼Ⱥеһˣһ˵淴
߶ֱܵ𺦡ѧձϣ͹ʡ⿴ȥ
͹ʹʹʱٹ͹ˣӶᵼǵ͹ʵĹ
پҵᣬҲ˵ʹһݵ͹ʹ˵ͬʱʹһݵ͹
ʹ

      (3)⹲һ
      ˳㲵һ춹񻰡Ϊ½ɽ
ΪʵˡءߣӮ˹ƶũ֧ӵ
ʵȻڻСƽһƪд1947꣬˴ͦ
ɽо⣬һҪе⡣
ǡоģָƣʵߣն
˵ǡȡƵĲԣȺڡ
Сƽͬ־Ըëϯд˸棬һüϢƽ
ءڶȡָơë׼˵Сƽߣʹýž
սĵλõĸ(顷־19974º)ɴ˿ɼ
սʱڣáء߲ûΪԼӮöȺڵ
֧ӵ෴ˡȺڡҲûмֲáֻǵ˸
ʤƴȨ֮ᣬٹ˼ѲȺڣس׵ʵ
һߡ
      ʵдصߣռƶũһӾ͵õ
˺ܴ棬ΪʲôûΪԼӮȺڵ֧֣¡Ⱥڡ
?ԭܶࡣȣڵʱйũ壬˺͸˵Ĺϵһô(
仹)ƽ޹ʵشˣҲδضùȥ
Σǿ˵˶Ը˵ȨһϰԵĿ־壬¡š
ҲǺ޸ݡΪҪһǣ˽йٹ̣һ
ˣˣҲ˽вȨĺԣҲδػӭ˵Ĳ
Ǵµĳ档˽֪Ӧ
ءũУũ٣åƦӣ¡ڡѩѪ졷
дЩĿУ''õĿںź롱ũ
񲢲ӭںšֹΪᡱ򡱣ʵǷӳ
ũصĹʶ
      ɴˣҲͽһʷƣΪʲôͬũ
м廯չǿҵķڼ廯ĹгѪȺͱ
йũļ廯Ե˳ƽ?˵ũصΪʲôй
ũڵûʩӶѹ¾͹ԹԵذԼոյõֽȥ
?ԭġӱϿƺʵ֡ǽСũ
˽ơʵȻΪй쵼ıǶ˽вȨĴֱ̤
ǹˡƻ˽ɱƶֵص˲
ʶԼǹ͵ģ˵١ũ񽻳أ߼
廯·ʱũķԺ͵ơ

һơ൳

      (1)һƼһר
      νһƣ ָһֻһָһִ
Ʃй˹⣬а˸νɣǣ1949
йһֱɹִйһơ
      ǣһֲͬνһںܳһʱڣձһֱ
һִ̨壬ǹִǣձ
̨壬ЩҲִܹк
ƽ빫ƽľϣǫִ̈̄Ļᡣձ̨
ԳΪһ󣬵һơ
      ˣνһƣʵָһרơһ£ûбĵ
ǲ׼бĵûбĵִĵλսǲ׼бĵ
ִսûСһ£׼Сһ¡һµһ
ִʵִñֹֹ֣ƽȾȨ
һΪר绤۵ϾйĿǰ
й½Ψһһ֧֯ȻˣȻƴضɱΨ
Ψ

      (2)һ?
      һ¿ɷʵ?ѧΪǿܵģ˷ɭ(C.B.Macphers
on)ΪõյԱϽϾ߿ԣԱڵȷʵĳȨ
ȷڲͬɱôһԭҲȷп
ʵҲкܶѧ߲޳ɴһ۵㡣(G.Sartori)ָڲ
ɱԭϲͬ춲֮ͬ໥Ϊǰ಻ȡ
Աֻ֧֣߲ȡڵ֧֡⣬ڵɱֻȨ
βûбȻϵ
      ҲνһڹŴϣڽĳڣ
˵һ˵ǣȫϾҲ
ӸϲͬȫˣνйΪɣΪй
ᡢäڶ࣬Բʵ۵ǿԷڵȻھø
ϣԡһȸôθĸϣΪʲôáһ
?Ϥйڲһֱ˻ĴĴһ
ĳЩνʿʹԼԵҲڹĴֶ
Ļֵֵ̬֧֣ùġ
      ҲҪָʵϺѳΪԱʸһֿ
۵Ľ綨ȥʵвȫԲȨƲ״
Ļ̶ȡԼԱһ͹Ϊ׼޶塣Աʸ
ȻֻҪ־Ը룬֯ͬܣͿԳΪԱִ
ֻеԱвȨô˾ͿܶҪ뵳Ȼʱ
ɱѾϷڣôڸɶΪ׳Լһɵʵƴ
ʿ뵳ڣܿϾͱúȫûʲô
ͼڲɱƵĿԣԵͻʶ̬ɿᵳ
ڲͬ۵㡢ͬɱʿƱؾ̸ˡ˵һҪ
ڲݲͬɱ춷ѣҪ󵳵ʶ̬൱İԣ
ǹʶ̬İԱͺܵͣοѾԱ
      ʵϣһƲζִñֹͬĳֲ֮ƽ
һζִ쵼ñֹڲͬɱĳֲ֮
ȨרƵİ취ιרƵİ취ενһר
ƣ˵ڶȫʵרƣ˵ڶȫʵר
ƣȫʵרơˣȡһרƣʵϾҪȡִߵ
ֵľȨⲻԵҲԾ󲿷ֵԱ

      (3)ƺͶ൳
      ǰ˵һƼһרơƱȻƻ൳
ơ
      νƣָһֻֻ֮ƾ
УִҲеĵԼ
һ㲻к󵳷ͥʵûִĻᡣ൳
ָһϣûһоƣΪһ
      ѧ(D.W.Rae)һķ׼ڹ
ռϯεܺռ90%ϣκһϯγ70%ߣΪƣ
һϯγ70%ϣһƣһϯγ70%ϣ
ϯܺҲδ90%ϣж൳ơ
      Ҫ˵ǣʵûһƶȽƻж൳(һ
)ĳɽĲ䲢ûĹ涨(
ֻǧ˵̨壬ǼעͶʮ)ƶȶ
£ѡٵĽȫпܷ仯Ʃ̨壬кü
Ӯ70%ϵϯΣ׵ı׼Ӧð̨һƣ
⼸ѡУ񵳵ϯε70%ϯܺͳ90%
ƣµһͻټҲֹѹ񵳺
ϯܺѹ90%µľ棬˵ֱɶ൳?
      ˵һʵĹ׳һľ
棬۵ľ棬ֻǶ൳ľ棬ҲǴżȻġ
صĹϵܴһǸ̶ȣһѡƶȡһڲ
Ƚص塢ԡڽ̡Ļʶ̬ȳͻôܻܿ
ֶʵµͻֶ൳ľ棬Ҳƽ˵
൳ơڲԲôȽϿܳΪľ棬Ҳ
νơֺѡƶйأñѡƣп
Ϊ൳ơ

      (4)ѡƶȶѵӰ죬άȷ
      ֪ѡƶҪ֣һԻһѡƣһԻơ
һЩѡƶȽ֮䣬(ͶƱ)ͻ
ƪֻǰѡơ
      յһѡƣÿһѡֻѡһˡƶ£Сĺѡ˵
ѡἫСԭ֧Сѡ˵ѡΪ˲ʹԼһƱװ˷ѣͨ
ƱתͶȽϽӽĳһ󵳵ĺѡˣǾγŵ
档ձƣݵƱٵıϯΣСҲзֵ
ϯεĻᣬʶγɶ൳ľ档ѡƶϵĹɣһ
֮Ϊάȷ(Duverger's Law:άһλѧ)
      Ҫǣڵһѡ£γŵľ棬
ѡ첻ôѡͬȫͳ
ơ˵ھ󲿷ѡǼ׵ҵۣôҾͽ
Ǽ׵ҵ۵ơѡܴһЩ
춾һЩ˵ЩǼ׵ҵ棬һЩ
Ǽ׵ͱҵͱͶ棬ȫΧ
ûرռƣȫԿܳΪ൳Ƶ״̬һ
ΪڲԲν˵׳Ϊ൳
ǵ͵ơ֪ʵеһѡƣɼѡƶȻ
ѲܴӰ졣
      Ȼ֮ԳΪƶûгΪ൳ƣҲҪ
ԭȣȨεҪŷ޵İˣҪ½ͽ
ڲԲ󣬸ϵһѡ֮ʶγơ
ĶԷչڲӣǰ
γɣһʵò࣬󲿷
Ҳֵòֱӽԭеֵİ취ʵԼҪƾ
ɹһֱάֵڡ
      ˱Թ˵й˲ŽɽͷΪ
ʵΪײΪţᡱ֮飬ǶйΪȻάȷǣ
СҲʤ£һ˶ɼС˴֮䲻Эϲ
󵳣ֻСܻʤ£ӽСԸϲɴ󵳡
˵ӽСǷԸϳɴ壬ǺνԻĻͳĹ
ϵСǺ̬ƼƵĹϵ
      һѡƺͱƸסδй춲ȡѡƶ
һܸӵ⣬֡ݲۼ

תڵ

      (1)֮֮ʵ
      תڵ⣬ʷһ⡣
      ǰͿϵ¶УС;ѡķʽһ
ʵָµԱʽ
ȡȨάȨĸרƵҲڷµ
ӵ֯ƩȻһרƣںƽĿžѡй½Ȼ
־ʿ˷Ե޷;ѡķʽȡȨ޷
ĹܣĽɫԻ̸ʵֽ׶
ãʵϺƵ޼
      ڲڿžѡĽ׶ΣԵܷӷԵĹܣȻһ
ֱ˻鵳Ϊ鵳ζ򡰵ֱӳȷر
Ҫ͹ķȨľĺͼԻǺȡĻ
ʽһһ岻һƣȥû
Եţ˹ѡֻýܹ˹
ԵţΪṩڹ֮һѡܰ˶
ߵһ½׶Ρ
      Ҳкܶ˳춲ԵĿǲֽ׶鵳ǿڹר£
񲢲ûѡĶ󣬶ûѡȨûѡǲ׼ѡ
ҲˣѡǵȻ춵ǶΪ
޸õѡ󡪡붼֪ɼⲻ
ṩѡĶ󣬶춺һѡȨˣ˵ĵ֮
ӦȡȨ⣬ȡȨΪ٣ָѹƣȺڸ
룬ӮͻƣӮʤһȨ֣ˮ
ˡ
      ǰնת͵ĹУԵõ˳ɫ֤֪
ȡͻƵЩң˶ȡȨΪ٣ȡ
̳һʽķ˶ǲȡŽṤ
ʽֱӲȡʽܻǧ֮ƣʹֳ
?˵ģǾǡһʽﵽͬЧƩ˵
һǿ֯ʵۺЧʸߣܹǶԱа
Եġٸ˵֯ǣϴεѡ
òԣΪûвμͶƱͨƶµѡ٣
һġʣǲԸøʽԵηʽﵽ
Ŀ𣿡߷𣺡Ը⣬ȻôãΪʲôҪͷȥ
ײأ֪ڣǿⲻ춽ʲô֣ؼ
Ӯù㷺Ĳ룬ǿʵӶܷá
      ȥһںţλ֯֯λ
ںűͬĲ˼롣λҪȡ֯ʽԶ
ռ䣬֯ҪȡλʽĴءʱ򣬴
֯֯תӷתǺ׵顣ŽṤᲢ
Ծӣ忪רƴբѡ٣ȻȻؾͳѡ
дȫʤ˵һ֯ǲƣܷӵ
áաһǵǵһա

      (2)ת
      һγɣͨкǿȶԺԡΪ
γȻġ֮ԷֳɲͬΪͬͬ
θ죬Ϊĳһشϼֲͬţֲͬͬ
ͬŵıᣬ̵طӳͬѧͬ
ͬһˣԹȥ͵µͬƵĹ۵㣬
ҶֵⳣҲȻȻسͬƵĹ۵㣬֮
ͬ־ϵñȽȹ̣ڲ׳ִķֻ飬ͬʱ
ѡеĵλԼϵķҲټ
      תڼȴȻڲܲȶ
ĵλҲܲȶϷشķֻ顣ŽṤᣬ
ŽսĹʷ;þĽܳ䣬ȡĶлܱ
Ϊһ壬һʵ֣Ѹٷֻѡ
      ڡṲƶơڴ촬(Institutional D
esign in Post-communist SocietiesRebuilding the Ship at Sea)һУ
ָ:жŷҵǹʱǹԵģΪ
ǿת͹̱Ӧ˶ת͡Ҫ˥Ȩ
ĸǲǲ춾ɵĹڲһµĸ졢ȷ
ʶ̬ĸĸƻʵ֯ʱԵģΪθ
еĵλΪӦת͵ҪԵµĸֳᣬǾͲɱ
ٽˡ
      ⡣ԷΪŽṤᣬŽṤǰѴɡ
Ѵɡ֮£ۼ桢ι۵ܲͬĸɫ˵ȡ
ܾ֮ۼһ𣬽ΪǶԹרơñһȺɫɫ
ͽΨһͬԸǶʶγɢϵ˶
һͽǱ㲻ɱظˡת͵һʱŽ
ᡢ̳һ֯ɹذĽɫֵķչܿؾ֤
ʵϸϵΪǵĳԱûͳһǵĳ
ԱԹֲͬǱ˴֮ȴͬǰûб
Ҫȥ˴֮ĲͬҲע˴֮便ʲôͬһ
רƿ̨ԭȰѴϵһĹʶ㲻ڣµĸָ
֮ķ¶ˡǣµ£ǲɱطֻ顣
      ҪֻԭִҲҪֻ˵ȵĹǻ춹ͬ
ôֹͬ𣻵ԱĹ۵ͱ廨ţֻڵ
͵ӲԼԡһʵοţŸ⣬
ķؽЩ˻ڵڣͼԼŸԭȵĵϾ
ԭȵĵܻӵһʿɹ۵ԴԼ̳ãҲЩ˻ϵ
Ϊϵпɹ۵ŲҲӴĸծЩǰе
һɻһɽϡ
      ӶŷתڼһЩص㡣˵
̶֯ȳȽ˻̶Ƚǿ
      صһԭҪǰϸԡǰ
ڲ췴˫£רʷԣڲ
֯ԳǱ³ǿһЩǰɷ棬˳춶ר
ʹܵ֯ʽ൱Уÿÿɢ˶ʽġ̳
ʽĻʽһṹά˵˸ѡӶĺѡ
мѡ񣬶Ǵĺѡмѡ⣬תڼ䣬
˺ܶǺǣ춴ڴýѡкܴӰ죻
֮£Щ֯õҪ
      ٽһתڵιסתڣɫʵ׷׳
̨࣬ϿνʮɫǣҪ֮Ĺϵ?֪
ս֮ҪĶڼշѧ߸(Fransois Furet)
۵㣬ͳɵĶʧȥԭеĲ(Ʃŷ޵
͹ں̶ܴ϶˹л)˫ĽޱģڶͶŷ
ǰ϶˹ţҪڼ;г
濴ȥû̫Ķھߺػش
ʱĳЩ˵ĵɣòڵļĳЩƻ
ġΣ()һʱ仹
εѪͻǰ˹Ϊһ
      ϣᵽתεһЩص㡣οǣʱƣ
ܶ𽥵Կ˷ǵӹȨת͵ľ޴ѣ
ǿǵרµľ޴ծǱ˵һתͻǽеñȽϳ
ġ

      (3)Ȩһ
      תڼķֻ飬ֵ̨ע⡣̨壬
ȻִȻķԵ˵ΨһĶִвķ
Ƶ֮ʮ䣬ָֻδ䡣
      Ȼ̨壬ķֻ黹еġڹڲһ
ЩɵĴų⣬һµ
ڲЩԪͶ˳򵭳̫ƫ̨
л񵳣̨齨ȵȡǰҵ
ȣ̨ķֻҪСöࡣ
      ҿñȨĲ𡣴ƽ˵Թ
񵳣Ǹٵ⣻ԹǸ޵⡣Ҳ
ˡºȨ̨ʽ
֮ǰɾѡ俯ΪʿЭжϵ
ѡԼĥʵʲ;ṩһĿռ̨ӶΪ
鵳׼˸ʵҲʹ齨Ƚȶ֪
ѡٺʵʩĹγɵġֻ֮ͨѡٺʵʲ
ĥϣſγϵȽȶԼȽ
֡      
      Ҫһѡٵ塣ǰͬ춾ѡôоѡ
ж̶ȵľѡж̶ȵνѡĳ̶⣬
ָꡣһָ˭ܲμѡ?г깫һһƱ?ֻĳ
(Ʋ塢Ա)ֻǳ깫еһ?һָ
ѡʲô?иѡĹְѡٲֻһɾ?
      רϿ϶ѡȨʵһһƱѡٸų
ӶʹѡٸΪѡ٣˹רƵѡٳ̶ȵ㣬
ȵ㡣йĴѡ٣춴򲢷Ȩλ
ѡٲ塣
      ڣѡĹְѡٲһһƱֻһ
˲ѡȨģǲȫڹȥ̨ʵ
һһƱְϯλֻһݶ⿪žѡƩԺںܳһʱ
ֻһСϯλ⿪žѡζţʹʿɾѡӮȫ
ϯλԺĶϯλӶҲԺȨԾɱڹ
ѡٵȻƽϾʤѡѡ١Ҫǣڶ⿪ŵǲ
ϯλϣѡٻʵġѡڼ䣬ʿ˳Զ
ִ֮ݣִѡҲܷһƺą́
ҲֻҲǲȫҪֲȫ
һҪ?Ӧ˵ǰһҪ
      
ġС

      йתδʼҲûпʼδοʼ
»ܶ϶ڿԶ϶һǣйս֮·
֮·ΪߣӦ˵ľ飬ѧϰε
ۺ͹ǾֻʹԼ˼ʵͣڽϵ͵ĲΣ
й̡